Top 10 Loyalty Cards for Restaurants That Drive Customer Loyalty

Loyalty cards are a great way for restaurants to keep customers coming back. By offering rewards and incentives, they encourage repeat visits, which helps increase revenue. In this article, I'll take you through the best loyalty card programs in the restaurant industry, how they work, and the benefits they bring.

Quick tip

Want more regulars? Eat App's Loyalty Suite lets you reward your guests for their loyalty, encouraging them to return. Request a demo today!

Why loyalty cards matter for restaurants

Loyalty cards help build strong customer relationships and improve retention. They drive repeat business, boost spending, and provide valuable insights. When customers feel appreciated, they’re more likely to return, increasing revenue and loyalty.

Effective loyalty programs rely on regular customers. Offering rewards like points, discounts, or exclusives encourages more visits and higher spending, creating a win-win for both customers and businesses.

1. Loyalty cards increase repeat business

Loyalty programs encourage repeat business by offering rewards for customers who return. Customers often earn points or stamps when they join, and a points-based system can increase both visit frequency and order size by making each visit more rewarding.

Take Qdoba Rewards as an example. Customers earn points for every visit, with rewards like free entrees. By giving customers a reason to come back, restaurants can create a cycle of repeat business that drives revenue.

2. Loyalty cards improve customer spending

Loyalty programs also encourage customers to spend more during their visits. Studies show that 49% of consumers tend to spend more after joining a restaurant loyalty program. By offering points-based rewards, restaurants can motivate customers to choose higher-priced items or add extras to their orders.

These programs benefit restaurants by allowing them to choose rewards that match profit margins, reducing risk. Offering a free dessert or a discount on a high-margin item can increase the average order size, helping to improve the restaurant’s bottom line.

Pro tip

Use Eat App’s Loyalty Suite to reward loyal customers with personalized points and rewards, encouraging repeat visits and boosting growth! Request a demo today. 

3. Loyalty cards provide valuable customer insights

Beyond driving sales and repeat business, loyalty programs offer restaurants access to valuable customer data. Tracking purchasing habits helps restaurants understand customer preferences and tailor their offerings accordingly.

These insights can guide restaurants in crafting targeted promotions and personalized offers, enhancing customer engagement and satisfaction. For example, a restaurant might notice that a significant number of loyalty members prefer a particular dish and can create special promotions or discounts around it to drive even more sales.

Popular types of restaurant loyalty cards

Loyalty cards come in various forms, each designed to cater to different customer preferences and business goals. The main types of loyalty cards include points-based, item-based, and tiered systems.

These various types of loyalty cards can significantly enhance customer loyalty and promote repeat business.

Points-based loyalty cards

Points-based loyalty programs let customers earn points for every dollar spent, which can be redeemed for rewards. For example, at Zaxby’s, customers earn 10 points for each dollar spent, and Dunkin’ offers the same.

These points can be used for rewards like free items or discounts. Wendy’s loyalty program, for example, offers free desserts or cheeseburgers, plus birthday rewards. This system motivates customers to spend more to earn more points, driving repeat visits and increased spending.

Item-based loyalty cards

Item-based loyalty cards reward customers with specific items after a set number of purchases. For example, Costa Coffee’s Costa Club gives members a free drink after ten purchases.

Programs like My Chili’s Rewards offer new members free chips and salsa or a non-alcoholic beverage. This type of loyalty card encourages customers to return until they earn their reward.

Tiered loyalty cards

Tiered loyalty programs categorize customers into different levels with escalating rewards based on their spending levels. This system incentivizes customers to reach higher tiers for enhanced rewards, increasing engagement and loyalty.

PF Chang’s Rewards features Gold and Platinum tiers, offering differentiated incentives to its loyal customers. This approach not only rewards frequent customers but also motivates occasional visitors to increase their spending to reach higher tiers.

Key features of successful restaurant loyalty cards

A successful loyalty card program should align rewards with customer preferences to improve engagement. Essential features include:

• an easy enrollment process,
• user-friendly mobile app integration,
• and personalized rewards.

These elements make the loyalty program attractive and convenient for customers to use.

Easy enrollment process

A simple and quick sign-up process is really important for attracting new loyalty program members. A straightforward sign-up significantly increases customer participation, making them feel welcomed and appreciated from the start. This frictionless experience can lead to higher retention and loyalty.

User-friendly mobile app integration

User-friendly mobile app interfaces improve customer engagement by simplifying the tracking of points and rewards redemption. A complicated redemption process can discourage customers from using their rewards, so clear communication of how rewards can be redeemed is essential.

Personalized rewards and offers

Customizing rewards to individual preferences boosts the effectiveness of loyalty programs. Personalized rewards and offers can significantly boost customer engagement and retention, making customers feel valued and appreciated.

Examples of effective restaurant loyalty cards

Successful restaurant loyalty cards drive customer engagement and loyalty. Programs like Starbucks Rewards, Chick-fil-A One®, and Chipotle Rewards are excellent examples of how effective loyalty programs can be.

Starbucks rewards

Starbucks Rewards is a points-based system where members earn stars for purchases, including groceries and online items, which can be redeemed for food and drinks. The app lets users track stars, redeem rewards, and manage their accounts easily.

With 30.4 million members in the US, the program has strong customer engagement. It features two tiers: Green and Golden, with Golden Status achieved after earning 300 stars. This structure motivates customers to reach higher rewards, boosting loyalty.

Loyalty programs thrive on creating clear, attainable goals for customers, and Starbucks has nailed this by offering tangible rewards that keep members coming back.

Loyalty expert, Brian Woolf

Chick-fil-a one®

Chick-fil-A One® is a tiered rewards program that was launched in 2016. Members earn 10 points for every dollar spent, earning more points per dollar as they move up the membership tiers.

Some tiers allow members to give rewards to friends or family, adding a social element to the reward program.

Chipotle rewards

Chipotle’s loyalty program offers rewards such as free food, merchandise, or charitable donations. The points-based system allows customers to earn 10 points for every dollar spent, with additional points available through special challenges known as ‘Extras’.

The program incorporates gamification elements, engaging customers by allowing them to complete challenges for faster points accumulation. This approach keeps customers interested and actively participating in the loyalty program.

Benefits of implementing loyalty cards in your restaurant

Implementing loyalty cards in your restaurant offers numerous benefits, including boosting customer retention, increasing average order size, and providing valuable marketing insights.

A well-structured customer loyalty program can significantly enhance loyalty program visits and revenue.

Boosts customer retention

Loyalty cards help retain customers by rewarding repeat visits. For instance, 83% of customers are more likely to use the services of companies that offer a loyalty program. Programs like Costa Club use a mobile app and digital punch card to encourage customer engagement.

Gamifying purchases through points converts spending into a game-like experience, enticing customers to return. This approach ensures that customers remain interested and loyal to the restaurant.

Increases average order size

Loyalty programs encourage upselling, leading to increased sales through special offers. Promotions like Dunkin’s offers on espresso drinks and breakfast wrap combos incentivize customers to spend more during specific hours.

Integrating loyalty programs with mobile apps increases the reorder rate, average check size, and overall customer value. Offering high-margin items as rewards can maintain profit margins while encouraging larger orders.

Provides marketing insights

Data gathered from loyalty programs can help restaurants tailor their marketing strategies based on customer preferences. Understanding customer preferences allows restaurants to create targeted promotions that drive engagement and sales.

Tips for designing an effective restaurant loyalty card

Designing an effective restaurant loyalty card involves creating a program that is simple, valuable, and well-promoted. This ensures that customers understand the benefits and are motivated to participate.

Keep it simple and clear

Keeping loyalty card rules straightforward is crucial for attracting and retaining customers. A simple enrollment process and user-friendly mobile app integration make it easy for customers to track their points and redeem rewards.

Offer valuable rewards

Providing meaningful rewards that customers find valuable can significantly enhance their motivation to participate in the loyalty program. Customizable rewards can increase satisfaction and encourage continued participation.

Promote your loyalty program

Promoting your loyalty program is key to boosting enrollment and keeping customers engaged. Using social media can raise awareness and attract new members. Partnering with influencers can extend your reach and build trust. Eye-catching in-store signage can inform customers and encourage sign-ups.

How to measure the success of your loyalty card program

Evaluating a loyalty program’s success involves examining various key performance indicators (KPIs) that reflect customer engagement and retention. These metrics help determine the program’s effectiveness and guide data-driven decisions.

Track customer retention rates

Tracking customer retention rates helps measure how well a loyalty program encourages repeat visits. Higher retention rates show stronger customer loyalty and a successful program. To calculate retention, track the number of returning customers over a set period. Comparing retention rates before and after launching the program can reveal its impact on repeat business.

Monitor sales growth

Sales growth is often linked to loyalty programs, highlighting their effect on revenue. To assess sales growth, compare revenue before and after launching a loyalty program. Tracking sales data from loyalty members versus non-members also provides insights into the program's financial impact, helping restaurants see how it drives spending and increases revenue.

Analyze customer feedback

Analyzing customer feedback is crucial for improving loyalty programs and ensuring they meet customer expectations. Personalized rewards and offers based on customer preferences can significantly enhance engagement with the loyalty card program.

Common challenges and solutions for loyalty card programs

Restaurants may encounter difficulties in attracting customers to sign up for loyalty programs, often due to a lack of perceived value. Gathering customer feedback through surveys and reviews can provide insights into customer satisfaction and highlight areas for improvement.

Low enrollment rates

Insufficient marketing of the loyalty program can lead to low signup rates as potential members may not be aware of its existence. Offering immediate rewards upon signup can significantly increase the likelihood of customer enrollment, boosting overall customer retention.

Reward redemption issues

Customers often encounter challenges when attempting to redeem rewards, which can lead to dissatisfaction and decreased loyalty. Communicating clear terms and conditions ensures customers understand the redemption process and avoid confusion.

Maintaining customer interest

Tailoring rewards and offers to fit individual customer preferences enhances engagement and ensures ongoing interest in the loyalty card program.

Leveraging social media can effectively increase awareness and engagement in the loyalty card program, drawing in more customers.

Future trends in restaurant loyalty cards

Emerging trends in loyalty programs emphasize personalization, integrated technology, and sustainability.

Integrating digital platforms for customer engagement and rewards is becoming increasingly important.

Digital wallet integration

Loyalty programs are increasingly being integrated into mobile apps, allowing customers to manage points and redeem rewards through digital wallets. This integration simplifies the customer experience by allowing seamless transactions and reward redemptions through mobile applications.

AI-powered personalization

Artificial intelligence helps restaurants tailor their loyalty programs to individual customers, providing better overall experiences. Customized rewards based on customer preferences can significantly enhance customer engagement, leading to increased loyalty.

Sustainability-focused rewards

Loyalty programs are increasingly incorporating eco-friendly incentives. These rewards programs appeal to environmentally conscious consumers, aligning with the growing trend towards sustainability.

Best practices for promoting your loyalty card program

Promoting the promotional loyalty program through targeted marketing can significantly increase customer awareness and interest. Leveraging social media, partnering with influencers, and utilizing in-store signage are effective strategies.

Leverage social media

Using social media effectively can enhance visibility and engagement for loyalty programs. Platforms allow for engaging marketing, enabling restaurants to interact directly with customers and share updates about their loyalty programs.

Partner with influencers

Partnering with influencers allows restaurants to tap into their established audiences, bringing greater visibility to loyalty programs. Influencers can enhance a restaurant’s credibility, making their loyalty programs more appealing to potential customers.

Utilize in-store signage

Effective in-store signage can clearly outline the rules and structure of the loyalty program, making it easy for customers to understand their rewards. Engaging ways to earn points and low-cost rewards should be highlighted to attract customer interest.

Eat App's loyalty solution

Eat App’s Loyalty Suite simplifies the process of converting occasional visitors into loyal customers. The system automates the processes of tracking rewards and distributing them to guests, ensuring a smooth and data-informed rewards system that encourages repeat visits.

Summary

Loyalty cards are powerful tools for restaurants, driving customer loyalty and boosting revenue. By implementing well-designed loyalty programs, restaurants can enhance customer retention, increase spending, and gain valuable marketing insights.

Promoting the loyalty program effectively and leveraging emerging trends like digital wallet integration and AI-powered personalization can further enhance the program’s success. By following best practices and addressing common challenges, restaurants can create loyalty programs that truly resonate with their customers.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do loyalty cards increase repeat business?

Loyalty cards boost repeat business by rewarding customers with points or perks for each visit, making them feel valued and more likely to return. It's a win-win for both you and the business!

How can loyalty programs enhance customer spending?

Loyalty programs boost customer spending by rewarding them with points for purchases, which encourages them to buy more and choose pricier items. It's a smart way to keep customers coming back and spending more.

What types of loyalty cards are most popular?

Points-based, item-based, and tiered loyalty cards are the most popular types, as they cater to various customer preferences and business needs. Choose one that aligns with your shopping habits for the best rewards!

How can restaurants measure the success of their loyalty programs?

To measure the success of your loyalty program, keep an eye on customer retention rates, track sales growth, and analyze feedback to gauge how well the program is resonating with your customers. This will help you know if your efforts are truly paying off.

What are some common challenges with loyalty programs?

Loyalty programs often struggle with low enrollment, redemption problems, and keeping customers engaged. By improving marketing, offering straightforward terms, and personalizing rewards, these issues can be tackled effectively.