OpenTable vs. Resy: Which Reservation System Should You Pay For in 2026?

Two years ago, this was a simple question. OpenTable had the network, Resy had the cool kids, and restaurant owners picked based on which one mattered more to their dining room.

Then the credit card companies showed up with chequebooks.

American Express bought Tock for $400 million and folded it into Resy. DoorDash spent $1.2 billion on SevenRooms. OpenTable answered by signing a deal with Visa and quietly winning back a list of buzzy restaurants that had defected years earlier. As Resy and Eater co-founder Ben Leventhal told CNBC, three very large, very well-resourced companies are now fighting over the same slice of real estate: high-demand tables in big cities.

So the question isn’t just which app has the nicer floor plan. It’s which ecosystem you want your restaurant sitting inside for the next three years, and how much of your revenue you’re comfortable handing over for the privilege.

Below is the honest version: real 2026 pricing pulled from both companies’ own pages, the cost math at your actual cover volume, where each platform quietly falls down, and what to do if neither one fits. If you want the wider field first, our roundup of online restaurant reservation systems covers thirteen platforms.

OpenTable vs Resy: the short answer

Pick OpenTable if you need diner discovery. Roughly 60,000 restaurants, a consumer app most people already have on their phone, and the largest marketplace in the business. You pay for that reach on every network cover you book.

Pick Resy if you’re doing volume and you’d rather pay a flat fee. No per-cover fees at any tier, an American Express audience that spends heavily on dining, and a brand that still signals “hard to get in.”

The tipping point sits at roughly 110 network covers a month. Below that, OpenTable’s Basic plan is cheaper. Above it, Resy’s flat pricing wins and keeps winning as you get busier.

Everything else is detail, but the detail is where the money is.

The reservation wars, and why they changed your options

Three deals rewrote the map, and all of them landed fast enough that plenty of owners still haven’t caught up.

American Express + Tock (2024). Amex, which already owned Resy, paid $400 million for Tock. Starting in 2025, Resy began absorbing Tock’s roughly 5,000 restaurants, bars, and wineries, taking the combined count to about 25,000 venues. The practical result: Tock’s ticketing and prepayment technology now ships inside Resy’s plan lineup.

DoorDash + SevenRooms (2025). DoorDash announced the $1.2 billion, all-cash deal in May and closed it on June 13, 2025. SevenRooms became part of DoorDash’s commerce arm, which means the company that owns your delivery relationship now wants your dining room, your takeout, and your tables too.

OpenTable + Visa (2024). OpenTable and Visa launched the Visa Dining Collection in Los Angeles and Chicago in July 2024, holding primetime availability for Visa Infinite cardholders. It’s now live in dozens of North American cities.

Market share tells the same story from a different angle. Research from Analytics.Restaurant put OpenTable’s US share at 46%, down from 51% over two years. Yelp climbed eleven points. Toast Tables went from nothing to 5% of the market in about fifteen months, and 68% of those restaurants had never used a reservation platform before — Toast expanded the pie rather than stealing from it.

Why this matters to you: the platforms are competing on incentives right now. Deep discounts, waived onboarding, free months. If you’re switching in 2026, negotiate; nobody volunteers a better price point.

The other point worth making: every one of these platforms now sits inside a bigger tech company with an agenda of its own. Reservations aren’t really the product anymore. Your restaurant’s booking data is.

The credit card wars: perks are the new feature

Here’s the part that wasn’t on anyone’s evaluation checklist three years ago.

American Express is not in this business to sell table management software. It’s in it because card members spend close to $90 billion a year on dining, according to Resy’s CEO. Reservations are a retention tool for a premium card. Platinum members get Global Dining Access, early or exclusive tables at hard-to-book restaurants, plus an annual dining credit to spend at Resy restaurants. That’s a lot of motivated demand pointed at your door.

Visa’s version works the same way. Eligible Visa Infinite cardholders add their card to their OpenTable account and see and book prime-time slots regular users never see. Different card, same playbook.

Pre-pandemic, none of this existed. Card perks meant lounge access and cashback, and reservations were plumbing. Post-Covid, experiences became the thing premium cards compete on, and suddenly your 7 pm Friday tables are a marketing asset for a bank.

So when people frame this as OpenTable vs Resy, they’re partly arguing about credit card perks. Which is strange, and also correct.

What it means in practice:

• Amex cardholders skew high-spend. If your average check is north of $120, Resy puts you in front of exactly those customers.
• Visa has vastly more cards in circulation, so OpenTable’s program reaches wider but less precisely.
• Neither perk fills a slow Tuesday. Credit card companies are chasing the same buzzy restaurants everyone else is. Neighborhood restaurants doing $40 checks won’t feel much lift from either program.

Don’t choose a reservation platform for the perks alone. Do factor them in if you’re in a competitive city where a Friday night table is genuinely scarce.

OpenTable in 2026: the biggest network, and what it costs

OpenTable has been taking reservations since 1998 and remains the default name in American dining — people search for it as Open Table almost as often as they spell it correctly. Tens of millions of diners browse the app and website every month looking for somewhere to eat, and it plugs into more than a hundred booking partners around the world, from Google to travel and booking sites.

Under CEO Debby Soo the company has spent two years fixing its weakest link: the software itself. Table management got a serious rebuild, Smart Assign handles seating suggestions, and the mobile app finally shows a live floor plan. The Philadelphia Inquirer reported that OpenTable has been pulling acclaimed restaurants back from Resy and Tock with better features, aggressive discounts, and the Visa program.

OpenTable pricing in 2026

Straight from OpenTable’s own published plans page, checked in August 2026:

• Basic — $149/month. $1.50 per network cover after a 30-day free window. Reservations you take through your own booking widget cost $0.25 each, or $49/month flat.
• Core — $299/month. $1 per network cover. Direct bookings included. Full table management, POS integration, access rules.
• Pro — $499/month. $1 per network cover. Adds 360 guest profiles, automated email campaigns, guest tagging, post-dining surveys.

Two things to note. First, prepaid experiences and ticketing carry a 2% service fee across all tiers, that’s newer, and it stings if events are a real revenue line for you. Second, the standard contract runs a year and auto-renews unless you give 30 days’ notice.

To OpenTable’s credit, cover fees only apply to seated guests. No-shows and cancellations aren’t billed, and phone bookings and walk-ins are free. Whether you write it OpenTable or Open Table, that part of the model is fair.

What OpenTable does well

• The largest diner network in the business, full stop
• Genuinely strong discovery for new openings and restaurants in tourist-heavy cities
• Diner loyalty points that give guests a reason to book through the app
• Deep POS integration, payments support and reporting you can benchmark against your market
• Visa Dining Collection exposure at no extra charge

Where OpenTable frustrates owners

• Per-cover fees scale with your success. Book 1,500 network covers a month on Core and you’re at $1,799 before anything else.
• Guest data lives in their ecosystem as much as yours, and competing restaurants can advertise against your listing.
• The best CRM and marketing automation sit behind the $499 tier.
• Table management still assumes an iPad at the host stand.

If those trade-offs bother you, we’ve mapped the field in our guide to OpenTable alternatives.

Resy in 2026: flat pricing and the Amex halo

Resy is a different animal. It never tried to out-scale Open Table; it built a reputation instead. Don Angie, Lilia, Carbone — the restaurants people set alarms to book tend to live on Resy, and that association still does real marketing work in NYC, LA and Chicago.

Since the Tock acquisition, the lineup has been rebuilt around two tracks: the Resy platform for straightforward reservations and table management, and Tock-powered plans for restaurants selling events, tastings and prepaid seats.

Resy pricing in 2026

From Resy’s own published plans and pricing page, checked August 2026:

• Platform — $289/month. Reservations, table management, waitlists, POS integrations.
• Essential — $289/month. Tock-powered. Events, ticketing, deeper customization, 3% fee on prepayments.
• Platform 360 — $459/month. Everything in Platform plus the advanced analytics dashboard and automated guest insights.
• Premium — $459/month. Everything in Essential plus a lower 2% prepayment fee, POS integrations and priority phone support.

No per-cover fees at any tier. That’s the whole pitch, and it’s a good one. Tock-powered plans also include chargeback coverage up to $25,000 a year, which matters if you’re taking deposits and payments at volume.

What Resy does well

• A flat fee that doesn’t punish a strong Saturday
• Amex Global Dining Access and a card-member audience with money to spend
• Priority Notify on higher tiers, which turns cancellations back into covers automatically
• Serious event and prepayment tooling inherited from Tock
• Strong presence in dense urban markets like NYC where reservations are competitive

Where Resy frustrates owners

• $289 is a hard floor. There’s no small-room plan and no free tier.
• Analytics and guest insights require the $459 step up.
• Marketing automation is thin — most operators end up wiring in a separate email tool.
• Coverage outside major North American cities is patchy. If you’re in a small town, the Resy brand isn’t doing much for you.
• Support is chat and email on the lower tiers. If you’ve had terrible experiences with ticket queues elsewhere, ask about phone access before you sign.
• Still an iPad-first product at the host stand.

Reservation system costs: run the numbers on your own covers

Forget the sticker prices. Here’s what two comparable restaurants with the same number of tables actually pay, assuming a 60/40 split between network bookings and direct bookings.

At 100 covers a month, Open Table Basic is the cheapest option on the board. At 500, Resy costs less than half of either OpenTable tier. At 1,000 network-heavy covers you’re paying OpenTable roughly $10,800 a year against Resy’s $3,468.

Now the counter-argument, because it’s a real one: if the OpenTable network genuinely brings you 300 covers a month you wouldn’t have gotten otherwise, $600 is cheap customer acquisition. The question isn’t what you’re paying. It’s whether those guests would have found you anyway through Google, Instagram or your own site.

Most restaurants never check. Pull a booking-source report before you renew anything — it will tell you more than this article can. Two restaurants with identical covers can land on wildly different bills, purely because of where guests book their reservations.

Who really owns your customer data?

This is the quiet part, and it decides more than pricing does.

Every reservation creates a record: name, phone, contact preferences, allergies, spend, how many times they’ve dined with you. Whoever controls that database controls your ability to bring people back without buying that introduction twice.

OpenTable gives you guest profiles, and the full 360 version on Pro is genuinely good. But the diner relationship is shared with the marketplace, and the marketplace is also showing your competitors to the same person. Resy is better on this point — data ownership is cleaner, and Amex isn’t trying to resell your regulars to the restaurant down the block. Neither, though, hands you a marketing engine.

Ask any platform three questions before you sign:

1. Can I export my full guest database, including contact details, whenever I want?
2. Do you show my competitors to diners looking at my listing?
3. What happens to my customer data if I leave?

If a sales rep gets vague on any of those, that’s your answer. Restaurants that focus on repeat business care about this far more than the ones chasing new customers every week.

Feature by feature: two reservation platform philosophies

The pattern is clear enough. OpenTable is a marketplace that grew a software product. Resy is a software product wearing a very good brand, now attached to a bank. Neither was built around owning the guest relationship end to end, which is why so many restaurants bolt on a separate CRM for restaurants or marketing tool anyway.

Which one fills a popular restaurant faster?

Depends on your city and how familiar diners already are with your name.

If you’re a popular restaurant in Brooklyn or downtown NYC with a two-week wait, the OpenTable network is close to worthless to you — every table sells regardless, and the tables you can’t sell are the ones nobody wants to book at 5:15pm anyway. What you want is pacing control, no-show protection and a guest database you own. Resy’s flat pricing makes sense, and the Amex association reinforces the positioning you already have.

If you just opened in a second-tier city and nobody knows your name, discovery is the whole game. The OpenTable app is where people go when they’ve decided to eat out but haven’t decided where. Paying $1 a head to get found is defensible, at least for the first year.

And if you’re a neighborhood spot with regulars and a Google Business profile that does the work? Honestly, neither. You’re on big-city pricing for a problem you don’t have. Take direct bookings from your website and Instagram, keep the money, and put it into service.

That’s the point most comparison articles miss. The right answer depends less on the software than on where your covers currently come from.

Booking restaurant reservations as a diner: both apps compared

Worth understanding, because this is where your guests book their reservations.

OpenTable is the generalist. Far more restaurants, a points program (1,000 points converts to a $10 dining reward), Notify Me alerts, and integration with search, hotel and travel apps. If someone’s booking dinner in an unfamiliar city, this is usually the app they open.

Resy is the specialist platform. Fewer restaurants, but a higher hit rate on the tables people are actually chasing. Notify works well, Global Dining Access unlocks reservations nobody else sees, and the app has a curated feel OpenTable’s doesn’t.

Serious diners keep both, because restaurants typically sign with one platform exclusively. Which is exactly why your choice affects who finds you — a guest who only has Resy installed will never stumble across your OpenTable listing.

Looking for a Resy alternative or an OpenTable replacement

Plenty of restaurants land on “neither.” The economics are steep at both ends, and the market has moved: diners increasingly find restaurants through search, Maps and Instagram rather than marketplace apps, which weakens the core argument for paying network fees at all.

Eat App is the direct-booking answer. Free plan, then $99/month, with no per-cover fees on any tier. It runs on iPad, web, Android and desktop rather than locking you to one device, includes a built-in guest CRM and marketing automation on paid plans, and uses AI restaurant software for no-show prediction, wait-time estimates and automated campaigns. POS integration matches reservations to spend automatically instead of making a host key in a check ID. You own your customer data outright. Full details sit on the pricing page, and our restaurant reservation software overview covers the feature set.

SevenRooms, now inside DoorDash, is worth a look if delivery is a meaningful channel and you want takeout, delivery and dine-in guest history in one place. Enterprise-priced, and the roadmap belongs to DoorDash now.

Toast Tables makes obvious sense if your restaurants already run Toast at the point of sale. The integration is native and the price point is modest. Floor plan tooling is less mature than either platform above.

Yelp Guest Manager punches above its weight in cities where Yelp still drives discovery, San Diego being the standout example. Compare the two directly in our Yelp vs OpenTable breakdown.

For the full field, see our guides to Resy alternatives and the best restaurant reservation software apps in United States for 2026.

Switching platforms without wrecking your service

Four things go wrong, every time:

Your guest data doesn’t come with you automatically. Ask for an export before you cancel, not after. Some companies make this deliberately slow.

Your booking links break. Update your Reserve with Google connection, your website widget and your social booking buttons on day one or you’ll spend a fortnight wondering where your online bookings went.

Staff training gets skipped. Run a full week of parallel service if you can. A host fumbling a new floor plan during a Friday rush is a terrible way to introduce new technology, and guests notice.

Contract timing. Both major companies use annual auto-renewing terms. Diarise your notice date. Miss it by a week and it can cost you a year.

More failure points are covered in our piece on restaurant reservation software problems to avoid.

The verdict

If you want to be found: OpenTable. The network is real, the discovery works, and the tech has caught up. Accept that you’re renting access to diners and that the bill grows as you do.

If you want predictable costs and you’re busy: Resy. Flat pricing, an Amex audience with genuine spending power, and the strongest events tooling of the two now that Tock is folded in.

If you’re a smaller business, a hotel restaurant, or anywhere bookings already arrive direct: seriously consider neither. A commission-free reservation platform with a real CRM will cost less and give you more control over the guest relationship. More importantly, it lets you create repeat business instead of renting it.

Both companies can be a good partner for the right room. Neither is a good partner for every room, and any reservation platform that tells you otherwise is selling you something. Leventhal’s framing is still the best test anyone’s offered: does this speak to how I run my restaurant, and does this speak to how I serve my customers? Answer that before you look at a single price point.

And if you want to see what commission-free looks like on your own floor plan, book a demo with Eat App. Bring your cover volume and your current fee structure, it’s a 30-minute walkthrough, tailored to your venue, with no obligation at the end of it. Restaurants running Eat App report a 90% drop in no-shows, 21% more online reservations, and $0 paid in reservation commissions.

More posts on restaurant reservations

• Tock vs OpenTable
• Eat App vs Table Agent
• Eat App vs Tablein
• Tablein alternatives
• Restaurant reservation system vs booking software
• Table management
• Software for restaurants